Is Your EAP Working? 5 Warning Signs It’s Letting Employees Down

Employee Assistance Programmes (EAPs) are supposed to be a safety net—confidential support employees can turn to when life gets hard. But in practice? Many are failing the people they’re meant to protect.

Some EAPs are underused. Some are outdated. Some are so buried in HR portals that employees don’t even know they exist. And in a world where mental health, burnout, and financial stress are rising, that’s not just a missed opportunity—it’s a risk.

So how do you know if your EAP is actually working?
Here are 5 common red flags to watch for.

1. Nobody’s using it

If your usage rate is under 5%, something’s not right.

Yes, support services won’t ever hit 100% adoption—but you should expect to see consistent engagement, especially in high-stress industries or periods of organisational change. If no one’s logging in, calling, or attending sessions, it likely means one of the following:

• Employees don’t know it exists
• They’re unsure what it covers
• They don’t trust it
• It’s too hard to access
• They tried it once—and were disappointed

Tip: Ask your provider for transparent usage stats. Compare those with employee survey data about wellbeing needs. If there's a gap, it needs addressing.

2. Support is limited to counselling

Traditional EAPs often focus solely on short-term counselling (usually capped at 6 sessions). That’s a helpful foundation—but it’s no longer enough.

Modern employees need support across multiple areas:

• Financial coaching for budgeting or debt
• Sleep and nutrition support
• Menopause and hormonal health clinics
• Help returning after parental leave
• Burnout prevention and stress management
• Guidance through divorce or abuse

When your EAP only offers one type of support, you force employees to fit into a single box—when real life is anything but linear.

3. Employees are being turned away or signposted to self-help

One of the most damaging experiences is when someone builds up the courage to ask for help… and hears:

“We can’t support you with that.”

Some EAPs operate on tight criteria. If your challenge doesn’t meet a certain threshold, you may be signposted—to a meditation app, a self-help article, or a GP.

It’s a moment that feels like rejection.

For employees already anxious, overwhelmed, or unsure whether they’re “struggling enough” to qualify for help, this only reinforces shame and silence. Many won’t reach out again.

A good provider meets people where they are, not just when they hit crisis point.

4. Access is clunky or outdated

Think about the average experience of trying to use your EAP.
Does it involve:

• Digging through the intranet?
• Remembering a separate login?
• Calling a generic helpline and explaining your issue to a stranger?
• Long wait times for follow-ups?

Every point of friction lowers the chance that someone in need will follow through. The most effective EAPs today make booking a session as simple as ordering lunch—ideally with digital booking, mobile-friendly portals, and rapid follow-up.

Because when someone’s struggling, they don’t want to “email support” and wait three days.

5. You can’t measure impact

If you’re unsure who’s using your EAP, how they’re engaging, and whether it’s actually helping—how do you know it's working?

Many EAPs provide surface-level reporting (e.g. total number of calls), but lack clarity on outcomes, themes, or even usage by department. Without data, it’s hard to make informed decisions—or get internal buy-in for broader wellbeing strategies.

You should be able to ask your provider:

• What are the most common presenting issues?
• What are the average satisfaction or outcome scores?
• How does our usage compare to industry benchmarks?

If you’re getting vague answers or limited transparency, that’s a problem.

So what now?

If you’ve seen even one of these red flags in your organisation, it’s worth asking:
Is your EAP actually supporting your people—or just ticking a compliance box?

A wellbeing programme that employees don’t trust or can’t access isn’t just ineffective—it’s potentially harmful. It sends the message that help exists… but not for you.

And in a world where burnout, presenteeism, and staff retention are daily concerns, you need more than a helpline. You need something real. Responsive. And relevant to the way people live and work today.

At ReechUs, we do things differently.

We’ve built an EAP-alternative that actually meets people where they are - whether they’re facing mental health challenges, financial pressure, or just trying to feel more like themselves again.

What we offer:

• Fast access to therapy (no weeks-long waits)
• Quarterly financial coaching sessions
• Personalised 90-day fitness programmes
• Specialist clinics (nutrition, menopause, domestic abuse, return to work)
• Drop-in support for stress, anxiety, and burnout
• Clear company-wide reporting (without compromising confidentiality)

There are no clunky portals. No gatekeeping. Just real support from qualified professionals—made simple and stigma-free.

📩 Want to see how ReechUs could support your team?
Start here →

‍